Original risk, R multiples and account returns
Separate completed-trade R, compounded equity and the changing cash base.
Follow quantities through each exit instead of crediting the entire position with the furthest target.
Price-level arithmetic and user-entered samples. A target ratio is neither a measured edge nor a guarantee of the stop fill.
A message can show three attractive targets while the account sells most of its quantity at the first one. Quoting the furthest target as the achieved payoff describes a price on a chart, not the completed trade. The useful question is how much of the original position left at each executable price, and what happened to the remainder. Keep intended allocation and actual fills in separate columns. Neither a screenshot nor a provider target-hit count supplies the missing quantities.
Start by choosing the unit of observation. One original position with several exits is normally one completed trade for a position-level win fraction. Splitting its profitable legs into multiple winners while counting the final stopped remainder as one loser changes the denominator. A leg-level report is possible, but it must be labelled and must not be compared directly to a position-level report.
Assume 100 shares entered at 100 with an original planned stop at 98. The original cash risk is 200 before costs. Fifty shares leave at 102 and fifty at 106. The first exit earns 100 cash units and the second earns 300, so the whole position earns 400, or 2R gross. It did not earn 3R on all shares. Deduct 20 cash units of all-in costs and the result becomes 380 / 200 = 1.9R net. These prices are invented teaching inputs.
Now change only the remainder: fifty shares still leave at 102, but fifty stop at 98. The gross result is zero and the same 20 cash-unit cost gives -0.1R. A partial target hit therefore need not create a winning completed position. A break-even stop on the remainder is also not necessarily a zero-cost exit for the whole trade. State whether a win means positive gross P&L or positive net P&L.
Moving the stop closer after the first exit does not shrink the historical denominator. Replacing original risk with current residual risk can turn ordinary profits into dramatic R multiples or make division impossible when residual risk is zero. Record changing exposure separately as a management history. For the completed position, retain original cash risk and the original quantity policy. If additional entries are allowed, define their capital and risk treatment before seeing outcomes.
Costs should follow the record rather than an attractive headline. Per-order fees can rise when one position uses more exits; financing can depend on holding duration and remaining size. The new worksheet intentionally uses one shared completed-trade cost to make its two-branch arithmetic transparent. It cannot price these path-dependent charges or substitute for broker statements.
Build a row for original quantity, each exit quantity, exit price, timestamp and fee. Confirm that total exited quantity equals the entered quantity after any documented adjustments. Preserve pending quantities rather than manufacturing a closing price. An order trigger and an execution are different events: the SEC stock-order bulletin explains why a stop trigger does not guarantee the eventual execution price. Apply that distinction without assuming stock rules describe every derivative or venue.
The final review should show planned weighted payoff, realised weighted payoff, net completed R and any unresolved quantity. Compare the same exit policy over the full eligible period, including losers and unfilled instructions. Do not use the clean winner example to estimate a success rate. A useful result is sometimes simply that the published target sequence cannot be reconciled to a complete position record.
Prepare three fictional positions with identical entry and original stop but different exit allocations. Let one exit fully at 3R, one exit equally at 1R and 3R, and one exit half at 1R with the remainder at -1R. Record gross completed results of 3R, 2R and 0R, then apply the same explicitly assumed completed-position cost. This separates the price path from the quantity policy.
Next leave part of one position open. Do not add a convenient closing value to make totals reconcile. Record closed quantity, remaining quantity and an open status, then explain why a completed-position statistic cannot yet include that row. This fixture checks accounting logic; it does not compare real exit strategies or prove the most distant target produces better results.
Documentation establishes the stated mechanism, not tested trading performance. Checked 9 October 2026; a later version can differ.
Separate completed-trade R, compounded equity and the changing cash base.
Stress a payoff assumption without pretending a favourable average bounds the next loss.
The new completed reference has 40 units exiting at 102, 30 at 106 and 30 at 96 from entry 100. Its gross contributions are 80, 180 and negative 120, totalling 140. After extra cost 20 the result is 120 cash, or 0.6R on original risk 200. It is one hypothetical completed position, not two winners and a loser. The three-leg calculator rejects quantities that fail to sum to the original 100. A still-open remainder belongs to another status rather than a convenient zero price or manufactured closing event.