Partial exits and effective reward-to-risk
Follow quantities through each exit instead of crediting the entire position with the furthest target.
Separate completed-trade R, compounded equity and the changing cash base.
Price-level arithmetic and user-entered samples. A target ratio is neither a measured edge nor a guarantee of the stop fill.
A trader can be up several R and have a modest account return, or show a high account return after risking a large fraction of cash. These are different measurements. One R is a declared cash-risk amount associated with a position; an account percentage uses an account-value denominator. A sum of R values becomes neither a funded equity curve nor a compounded return simply because it is plotted over time. Identify the object being measured before choosing a chart title.
Write a small measurement contract before entering the series: currency, original position quantity, original stop distance, multiplier, fee treatment, account equity time and cash-flow policy. The share-price calculator has no multiplier input and must not be used unchanged for futures, options or products with nonlinear payoff. Missing contract identity is a reason to stop the calculation, not assume a convenient unit.
Consider a 10,000 cash-unit account. A first position has 100 cash units of original risk and finishes at +2R, earning 200 net. A second has 300 cash units of original risk and finishes at -1R, losing 300 net. The sum of completed R is +1R, but the net cash change is -100. Without deposits, withdrawals or other holdings, the account moves from 10,000 to 9,900. A positive sum of R therefore does not establish a positive portfolio return.
If risk were truly constant at 100 cash units for both positions, the same R outcomes would instead net +100. That counterfactual is a sizing assumption, not the reported execution. Keep actual and standardized-risk results side by side. Never overwrite the actual quantity merely because a fixed-risk view produces a nicer chart.
Deposits increase cash without producing strategy profit; withdrawals reduce cash without creating a losing trade. A drawdown chart needs a declared cash-flow adjustment and valuation schedule. Closed-position R drawdown ignores intratrade adverse excursion, open losses and simultaneous exposure. Several positions can contribute modest individual R losses while together breaching an account constraint. Keep mark-to-market account history separate from the list of finished trades.
A compounding illustration also requires an explicit order. If each trade risks a constant fraction of current equity, its cash-risk denominator changes over time. Returns cannot be recovered from the R sum alone unless the sequence, risk fraction, overlap and cash-flow assumptions are supplied. Do not apply a fixed-fraction formula to overlapping positions while pretending every position used the same latest equity independently.
The realised-R tool deliberately exports a completed-position series and labels it as not being a portfolio return. Attach a separate original-risk ledger when interpreting the series. A flat value is a completed zero result, not an empty observation. Missing outcomes, still-open positions and unfilled calls need separate status rows; blank lines in the numeric input do not account for them. State how the completed subset relates to the full signal population.
Before sharing a conclusion, reconstruct three quantities: total net cash P&L, standardized completed R and the account equity change under the declared cash-flow convention. Explain differences rather than forcing agreement. Ask whether risk, quantities or costs changed during the sample, and retain original values after amendments. The best denominator is not the one that flatters a strategy: it is the one that matches a clearly defined question and can be reproduced from retained records.
Create a blank ledger with original cash risk, net cash P&L, completed R, account equity before entry and external cash flows. Recompute each R from its original denominator and compare the sum to net cash P&L. Deliberately use unequal risk amounts to check that the summaries need not share a sign. The disagreement is informative, not a software failure.
Then add an invented deposit between positions. Keep it out of strategy profit while retaining it in available funding. Explain which account-return convention you would use before attempting any percentage calculation. Do not select a method because it matches a provider headline. A reader should trace every denominator to a dated record and understand why standardized-risk diagnostics and funded performance answer different questions.
Documentation establishes the stated mechanism, not tested trading performance. Checked 9 October 2026; a later version can differ.
Follow quantities through each exit instead of crediting the entire position with the furthest target.
Stress a payoff assumption without pretending a favourable average bounds the next loss.
Original gross stop risk is quantity times reference loss distance times positive linear multiplier, before the declared additional cost. Net cash includes that cost once. The reference set states this choice so a reader can reproduce it without quietly replacing historical risk after a stop revision. This remains a completed-position convention, not a cash-funded account curve. No account weights, external flows or marks are supplied. The currency-conversion guide adds a distinct reporting-unit question; it does not turn the workbook's R values into current subscriber returns or alter the earlier unequal-risk example.