Slippage assumptions versus additional fees
Change the exit price and cost policy separately so their cash effects remain traceable.
An exit assumption is not a charge
Slippage can be expressed by replacing a reference exit with another assumed or actual transaction price. An additional fee is a separate cash amount. When a calculation has already changed the price to include an adverse execution effect, adding the same effect again as cost changes the policy twice. Record which price is the plan and which price is the scenario. Actual slippage measurement also needs the benchmark clock, order identity and transaction record; it cannot be recovered from a later chart alone. This article uses invented prices and supplies no measured distribution or vendor execution result.
Hold original risk constant across alternatives
Consider 100 long units entered at 100 with original stop reference 98 and multiplier one. The original gross planned risk is 200. An assumed exit at 98 creates gross P&L negative 200; an assumed exit at 97.50 creates negative 250. Additional cost 20 then gives negative 220 and negative 270 respectively. Their net R values are negative 1.1 and negative 1.35 on the same original denominator. Changing the denominator to the worse scenario loss would conceal the comparison. These are alternative liquidations, not a sequence of actual losses or a forecast of available exit prices.
Direction affects an adverse movement
For a long exit, a lower transaction price is adverse to the signed payoff. For a short closing exit, a higher price is adverse. A generic always-subtract-price rule can therefore reverse the meaning of a short stress. Keep direction and signed price movement attached to each quantity row. A linear multiplier can amplify the cash consequence without changing which side is adverse. This is arithmetic only; short financing, availability and nonlinear contract behaviour are separate issues. The new calculator supports the sign convention while making no claim that the hypothetical short can be established or closed under real account terms.
Use the source for the right question
Official stop-order material explains why a trigger need not equal the final transaction price. It does not provide strategy-specific probabilities or broker-specific slippage estimates. For a real comparison, retain reference time, order state, quantity, executed price, venue or account context and separately assessed charges. A still-open remainder cannot be made complete by assigning a convenient stressed exit without labelling it hypothetical. The unchanged original should stay beside every altered-price and altered-cost case. A correct difference identifies the consequence of a declared assumption, not the frequency of a future gap or the maximum loss an account can experience.
Completed invented payoff case
An invented reviewer compares the same 100-unit long with reference liquidation 98 and stressed liquidation 97.50. Extra fee 20 is unchanged and is charged once. The results are negative 1.1R and negative 1.35R on original gross risk 200. There is no observed execution sample or probability weight. A note that subtracts a further 50 of slippage from the second result would need a separate additional component, otherwise it repeats the price change already made.
| Object | Record | Bounded finding |
|---|---|---|
| Original denominator | 100 x (100 - 98) | 200 gross cash risk |
| Reference exit | 98; additional cost 20 | -220 cash; -1.1R |
| Worse exit | 97.50; same cost | -270 cash; -1.35R |
| Probability | Not supplied | No expected-loss inference |

Primary references and scope
Expanded source review: 13 October 2026. Documentation supports the stated mechanism, not a tested account, hypothetical fill or provider outcome.