Partial exits and effective reward-to-risk
Follow quantities through each exit instead of crediting the entire position with the furthest target.
Audit target credit, flat outcomes, original-risk denominators and cumulative-R summaries without inventing account performance.
Price-level arithmetic and user-entered samples. A target ratio is neither a measured edge nor a guarantee of the stop fill.
A multi-level signal can show attractive target distances while actual exits use different quantities. Credit each exited portion with its documented price. An invented half at +1R and half at +3R yields +2R gross for the whole position, not +3R. If the second half stops at -1R, the gross completed result is zero despite the first target being reached.
Keep unfilled entries and open remainders distinct from completed positions. A target announcement cannot establish the actual quantity sold or prove every subscriber executed there. A strategy that declares whole-position exits must not be silently converted to a partial-exit strategy merely for a flattering summary. These are accounting examples, not a comparison showing which exit policy performs best. Original instructions and execution reports determine what a real ledger can support.
Take a fictional closed population of twenty positions with gross outcomes: twelve at +1R, six at -2R and two at zero. Gross winning fraction is 12/20, or sixty percent. Excluding the flats gives 12/18, approximately 66.67 percent, but answers a different conditional question. Gross total is zero under these invented magnitudes, despite the majority of positions being positive.
If every completed position has additional cost 0.10R, net total becomes -2R and mean net result -0.10R. The two gross flats are now net losses. Classification must follow the declared gross or net convention rather than retain convenient flat labels after costs. These counts are fixtures, not observations. A high fraction alone cannot choose payoffs, estimate tail severity or establish a future profitable account.
Original cash risk is a historical denominator tied to the entry contract. Moving a stop to break-even does not make that original risk zero. An invented 150 cash gain on original 100 cash risk remains +1.50R. Dividing by a later zero distance is undefined, not evidence of an infinite return or extraordinary strategy efficiency.
Additions, reductions and separate entries require a declared grouping convention and lineage. A revised denominator should not be chosen after seeing which version produces the most impressive result. Keep original quantities, costs and stop assumptions alongside any later version. A timestamp proof covers only committed fields and cannot supply omitted risk or quantity values. No proprietary risk ledger is reconstructed here from promotional percentages or isolated screenshots.
Use two invented completed positions: +2R with original cash risk ten and -1R with original cash risk one hundred. Summed R is +1, but net cash across these already-net outcomes is +20 minus 100, or -80. The summaries have different signs because their monetary weights differ. Neither is automatically wrong; presenting them as the same object is the mistake.
An account return also needs capital, cash-flow and valuation conventions. Cumulative R decline from a prior R peak is not automatically an equity drawdown percentage. External deposits do not become strategy profit, and unrealised exposure cannot disappear because a closed ledger looks clean. Preserve all denominators before choosing a chart. These examples establish accounting distinctions, not an actual account loss, equity curve or performance benchmark.
A stop price describes a trigger or intended invalidation under an exact policy; it is not automatically a realised loss ceiling. Investor.gov distinguishes stock stop and stop-limit mechanisms, including price and non-execution trade-offs. Check the actual broker and instrument instead of generalising one educational mechanism to every product. A claimed maximum loss requires evidence beyond a planned distance.
Likewise, a conditional break-even winning fraction assumes payoffs and costs. It does not estimate the actual probability of success. NIST's proportion reference does not make overlapping or selected trades independent, and an interval for winning frequency is not an account-return interval. Without original observations, this article reports no confidence range, strategy significance or validated optimal ratio. Keep stress scenarios separately labelled rather than presenting them as measured market frequencies.
An audit should identify the affected metric, original convention, proposed correction and evidence behind it. Preserve the first ledger alongside the corrected version, including unresolved quantities. If a source lacks original prices or risk denominators, leave that part incomplete rather than filling it from a provider headline. A reproducible subtotal may be valid even when full account performance cannot yet be calculated.
The blank mistake record captures each issue and its impact on the conclusion. Reproduce the flat-population, unequal-risk and target-allocation fixtures before inspecting real records. Keep software checks separate from market evidence and no-review status separate from a fraud allegation. This guide does not certify a provider or invent missing trades. It gives a reader a specific way to challenge a precise-looking payoff summary and recognise what additional records would make it assessable.
| Object | Preserve | Do not infer |
|---|---|---|
| Allocation | Quantity-weighted exits and original risk | The furthest target is the realised payoff |
| Classification | Flat, gross and net conventions | Removing flats preserves the same win rate |
| Summary | R, cash and account denominators | Positive summed R guarantees positive cash |
Download blank review record (CSV)
Headers only. No trades, subscriber outcomes or operating receipts are supplied.
Documentation establishes the stated mechanism, not tested trading performance. Checked 10 October 2026; a later version can differ.
Follow quantities through each exit instead of crediting the entire position with the furthest target.
Separate completed-trade R, compounded equity and the changing cash base.
Stress a payoff assumption without pretending a favourable average bounds the next loss.
The new workbook makes the distant-target mistake visible with fixed original quantity: half at 102 and half at 106 earns 2R gross on the chosen stop denominator, not 3R. Cost reduces that to 1.9R. A positive first exit with the remainder at the stop instead yields negative 0.1R after cost. The cases are invented alternatives, not empirical exit-policy comparisons. The new precision engine prevents a software subtraction artefact but cannot repair missing original quantities, double-counted fees or a false claim that the target actually filled.